This is Gary Klugiewicz.
I am the director of training for Verbal Defense & Influence that I recently had an phone conversation with Doug Lynch, one of our Vistelar Trainers. He asked an an important question about the difference types of instructors that I wanted to share with you.
His question to people who provide instruction to others was What type of Instructor are you?
I asked him to provide his thoughts on this question that I posted below:
When I first started as an instructor, I proudly called myself a trainer. I was in front of people and telling stories, showing PowerPoints, getting a few laughs and told to come back again. I thought I could train. But, my students were failing to do what I needed them to do once they left the class. Was it me? Was it them? Was it both? Thus, started my journey.
I sought out mentors and coaches and was lucky enough to meet and learn from some of the best in the business; Gary Klugiewicz, Bob Lindsey, Peter Jaskulski, Dave and Betsy Smith, Jack Hoban, and about a dozen more. I am thankful for their patience and transfer of knowledge. It became apparent I was a Presenter, not a trainer. There was much more that needed to be accomplished in a classroom than just getting people to agree with what I was instructing.
Below is a small bit of that information to help instructors better understand what they are doing, what they are capable of and what they need to be able to perform to master a style/level. It helps us to explain to non-instructors what to look for and what to expect from different styles/levels. In most cases, these are levels, not styles. Instructors progress through them from 1 to 4 over a career/lifetime. But, there are always exceptions.
- Presenter / Presentation: Passive, lays out information for students. Minimal, if any, checks for understanding, learning and performance are done. To become a Presenter, one becomes proficient at public speaking and holding the audiences interest.
- Teacher / Teach: Passive, guides students through information, confirms cognitive knowledge.
- Trainer / Train: Active, students learn how to perform tasks, ability to perform under stress confirmed.
- Coach / Coaching: Efficient, mastery of the levels below them. Able to TRAIN people to be competent at any of the first three levels.
His categories illustrate an increase in both competency and effectiveness that I find thought-provoking. Do we want our instruction to merely provide information or do we want it to provide skills and changes in long-term behavior? As with most things, the answer depends on who you are instructing, your purpose, and the length of time you have to do it.
Please post your comments below.